In the News


Holly Doremus in the news:



Red-blue split seen in wood-burning suit

Holly Doremus quoted in The Washington Times, October 9, 2013

“Obviously, states that are more committed to environmental protection are more likely to file suit against EPA saying, ‘You’re not doing enough,’” said Ms. Doremus, who also serves as the co-director of Berkeley’s environmental law program. “States are on both sides of pushing EPA to regulate more and pushing EPA to regulation less,” she said.


Who would kill a monk seal?

Holly Doremus quoted in The New York Times, May 8, 2013

As Holly Doremus, an environmental legal scholar at the University of California, Berkeley, writes, America has saved so much without ever asking “how much wild nature society needs, and how much society can accept.”


Boxer bill to speed projects riles critics

Holly Doremus quoted in San Francisco Chronicle, May 6, 2013(requires registration)

Holly Doremus, a professor of environmental law at UC Berkeley, said the Boxer provisions go too far.  “There’s a big difference between being able to stall a project forever and having environmental review so compressed and so within the control of the action agency that it might as well not happen,” Doremus said.


Farmers vs. cities in the war for water

Holly Doremus quoted in American Public Media, Marketplace, April 11, 2013

“The idea is that the people who were using the water first, they get the first call on the water that there is,” explains Holly Doremus, an environmental law professor at UC Berkeley.


Conservationists use triage to determine which species to save and not

Holly Doremus quoted in Scientific American, July 23, 2012 (subscription required)

“The environmental community was always unwilling to talk about triage,” says Holly Doremus, a law professor at the University of California, Berkeley. “Even though they knew it was going on, they were unwilling to talk about it.”


Delta’s woes: No easy fix, report finds

Holly Doremus quoted in Contra Costa Times, March 29, 2012

Doremus noted the committee did not weigh in on plans to move water around the Delta. The committee wrote there are not enough details available for it to analyze…. “Diverters were hoping the report would point a finger at other stressors as more important, which it didn’t,” Doremus wrote.


Farmers gain ground in California water wars as bill passes House

Holly Doremus quoted in The Sacramento Bee, March 15, 2012

“It didn’t work,” said Holly Doremus, a UC Berkeley law professor and California water expert. “It’s widely regarded as a failure as a way to put in place balanced management of the Bay-Delta.”


Controversy over Calif. oyster farm becomes a battle of the form letters

Holly Doremus quoted in Environment & Energy News, March 9, 2012

“There are sort of two separate games going on―there’s the legal game and the political game,” Doremus said. “The fact that [NPS] may be playing a political game that fans of the farm may think is hard doesn’t mean anything is legally wrong with the NEPA process.”


U.S. House approves bill that would remake California water law

Holly Doremus quoted in Los Angeles Times, March 1, 2012

“Part of what it tries to do is turn back time,” said UC Berkeley law professor Holly Doremus. “It’s a remarkable overreach. It tries to give the irrigators everything. They threw all of the wish list in here.”


GHG rule ‘tailored’ to suit administration, says industry

Holly Doremus quoted in Environment & Energy News, March 1, 2012

“It is a big challenge for EPA,” said Doremus. “It is absolutely clear that they’re rejecting specific words of statute.”


The legal odyssey to curb greenhouse gases opens a new chapter on a warm February day

Holly Doremus quoted in Environment & Energy News, February 29, 2012

“The Bush administration did nothing,” agreed Holly Doremus, a professor of environmental law at the University of California, Berkeley, School of Law. “The Obama administration EPA started exploring what they must and could do under the Clean Air Act.”


Holly Doremus Supports Judge’s NEPA Opinion

Environment & Energy News, February 3, 2012 by Lawrence Hurley
http://www.eenews.net/public/eenewspm/2012/02/03/1

“As Fletcher writes, it has long been the rule that agencies must evaluate the environmental consequences of their actions when it is reasonably possible to do so.”


Holly Doremus Explains Preemption Dilemma in Air Pollution Case

Daily Journal, December 28, 2011 by Fiona Smith
http://bit.ly/A1iJm3 (registration required)

“The [Supreme] Court doesn’t seem to have come out with any clear doctrine, especially on when and to what extent they should presume state legislation is valid and to what extent they should put their thumb on the scales on behalf of the states,” Doremus said.


Holly Doremus Comments on Wetlands Case

The Spokesman-Review, November 6, 2011 by Becky Kramer
http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2011/nov/06/private-land-public-battle/

“The fact that the Supreme Court decided to take this case suggests that at least four members of the court think that the circuit courts are getting it wrong,” she said.


Holly Doremus Commends Judge for Mastery of Water Laws

San Francisco Chronicle, September 25, 2011 by Gosia Wozniacka
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2011/09/24/BAG21L92R3.DTL

“I think those cases have been an incredible challenge,” said Holly Doremus, a law professor at UC Berkeley. “Judge Wanger took very seriously the task of sorting through the facts in these extremely complex, scientific cases.”


Holly Doremus Defends EPA

The New York Times, September 19, 2011 by Lawrence Hurley
http://nyti.ms/p31L8v

In defense of EPA, Berkeley’s Doremus dismissed the notion that the agency regularly throws its weight around by initiating enforcement proceedings against individual property owners like the Sacketts. That doesn’t happen, she said, because both EPA and the Army Corps “have been stung” in the past by efforts that have backfired politically.


Holly Doremus Says Wyoming Wolf Deal Is Not a Guarantee

The Billings Gazette, August 11, 2011 by Jeremy Pelzer
http://bit.ly/opFwkw

For one thing, she said, Fish and Wildlife biologists might be concerned whether Wyoming can accurately keep tabs on the state’s wolf population, given that wolves could be shot on sight without a license in part of the state. “They will have to do that process carefully,” Doremus said. “They’ll have to make sure they dot the procedural I’s and cross the T’s, because for sure they’re going to get sued.”


Holly Doremus Explains Why SCOTUS Chose EPA Case

The New York Times, July 11, 2011 by Lawrence Hurley
http://nyti.ms/qiqmbJ

Legal experts do agree that there are enough differences between the GE and Sackett cases to explain why the court did not treat them the same. Holly Doremus, an environmental law professor … noted, for example, that the conservative wing of the court has a particular problem with wetlands regulation, which it sees, in her words, as a “breathtaking expansion of federal authority into virtually every corner of the geographic world.” The Superfund law does not attract “the same overt hostility” from those justices, which include the outspoken Antonin Scalia.


Holly Doremus Comments on Threatened Railroad Lawsuit

Associated Press, June 21, 2011 by Noaki Schwartz
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2011/06/22/travel/main20073328.shtml

Holly Doremus, an environmental law professor at the University of California at Berkeley, said there has been debate over what constitutes solid waste, but in this case there’s no doubt the tiny toxic elements are waste…. “It’s not a slam dunk either way, and I think it’s very creative by the NRDC to have found this possibility,” she said.


Holly Doremus Extols Strength of Endangered Species Act

The New York Times, Room for Debate, April 22, 2011 by Holly Doremus
http://nyti.ms/gJUwh2

The great virtue of the Endangered Species Act is that it fights the human tendency to ignore problems indefinitely. It doesn’t force us to save endangered species, but it forces us to notice their plight. It’s a vital attention-getting device, and we need to be sure it continues to serve that purpose.